Відео

Wow Kathleen Stock is so refreshing. And a very pleasant tone from he interviewer. I'll check out some more videos 😄

As a child I remember my father once saying I was 'effeminate'. I looked the word up and was horrified, even then. I am a gay man, but I am a man. I've always been male. I've never felt any inclination to be female. To me it seems attitudes towards homosexuality still need to be improved. At work a gay couple came in for a medical test, and a colleague said 'which one is the woman?' That I think said a lot about how rigid people's ideas about homosexuality are. And perhaps this explains why gender identity trans activism has been bolted on to the struggle those who are 'same sex' attracted have faced, and why we also have the rise of the word 'queer' used as shorthand by anyone talking about not just the same sex attracted, the gender dysphoric, but heterosexual furries, sex workers, 'allies', kinksters, and anyone who doesn't conform to a very narrow idea of sexuality, effectively a monogamous heterosexual married couple that only ever use the missionary position.

Real Dems know that citizens are the Property of the State, and therefore property of the Government. Property has no rights, no voice, no choice but Obedience.

In order to defeat the authoritarian censorship (canceling) movement of the far left Cultural Marxists within Western society and particularly the academy…voting Trump at this point in time is a very good political decision.

Google's AI overview: According to a 2024 meta-analysis of studies conducted between 1939 and 2022, the average IQ of undergraduate college students in 2022 was 102, which is slightly higher than the general population average of 100. This is a 17-point decline from 1939, when the average IQ was around 119. The researchers attribute this decline to the increased accessibility of higher education over the past 80 years. One change this suggests is that the traditional mission of the university be revised accordingly (or, perhaps acknowledged).

Cornell faculty should be ashamed. Sheep.

Good panel, good talk. Thanks!

I am glad I retired when I did. College is not about education, it is not even about preparing people to work. I taught Sound Engineering for 15 years. Half the students admitted to the program will never have a future in sound engineering. And this is why most college graduates in Sound Engineering across America are doing something else within 2 years.

☕️

Extensive, root canal-level reform is needed. Some universities need to be "taken out behind the barn" because they are too far gone. 1. The value of "expertise" should come with an asterisk. In the sciences this is perhaps well understood, but there can be no such application to methodologically suspect areas like gender studies. 2. Educator advocacy organizations are hardly self-reflective. The "outing" of incompetent administrators in the last few years should be give one pause. Instead, most of these organizations engaged in gaslighting and shooting the messenger. 3. Education is now fully a business, with CEOs and customers. Failure to see this demonstrates blindness or willful ignorance. 4. The modern degree is merely a credential - a passport to the modern economy. Students are interested in education more generally. 5. Willfully ignoring the problem of rampant cheating and grade inflation is also part of the problem.

Beyond reform in the uk. But then the geopolitical and.economic is starting to take over fhe philosophical ones. Fees too high - home students moving to apprenticesjips. Chinese students in STEM challenging for security reasons. We've now moved on to "plunder" India for those profitable students, but we've got tye genai effext. This last 2 years attendance on campus collapsing. Bluntly the model is changing and fast. It's more about taking market share than growing the pie. I see a revolution in higher education inthe near future.

Imagine being called a pearl clutcher by these ball clutchers!

I remember her being hounded out of her university by tbe trans cult. It was shocking to me because she hadn't said anything untrue. She was so measured yet they hounded her out. No debate remember Stonewall manyra. I just like her. She's great. ❤

"puberty is a rite of passage" is such a sophist view showing that who ever spews this nonsense simply does not understand how early gender dysphoria forms and why. Women having children early and many "used to be a rite of passage to become an adult human female".Living unnaturally has changed this, we have the same right to determine our future not you that spew gender critical nonsense in your own self interest.

I think this is a huge problem for lesbians, as they literally don’t have any boobs to play with if most of their fellow lezs are converting to men. Leading to total lesbionic isolation. I can see why she is so angry and frustrated.

This interviewer interrupts excessively and consistently asks irrelevant questions.

Also, the interrupting. Come on, men. Please.

"A problem that needs to be solved" is a good way of describing the current malaise.

What is the deal with these MEN?!?! Why are you asking a woman who has received DEATH THREATS where she grew up and where her parents live????

and freedom of speech. You allow celebs and politicians to lie, you allow people to call for a country's distraction u allow profesors to teach your kids lies but a professor can't speak on her point of view ? Why are you so afraid to hear others pov? It's about diversity, isn't it

Justice for the Tavistock 16

Bring back the birch.. that fixes everything.

Wow! Never knew this inspirational woman was brought up in my birth town of Montrose. I am also classed as ‘English’ due to my Home Counties accent!

This is how warped the thinking has become supporting Transgen Ideology. I'm a disabled (gay) man and told I was transgender (by a trans) because my body didn't work and ergo, my body wasn't the body I was supposed to have, ergo I was trans. Thank God (philosophically) for Dr Stock.

Omg this is the type of sh!t the Transgender community has to deal with unfortunately. Who in the hell made this about yall. I am Trans and I dont give a damn about what YALL do with YALL body. If you don't identify as Trans I could care less do YALL boo. It becomes my business when you YALL try to erase the Transgender community. YALL have thrown us under ther bus several times. So don't cry foul now cuz people misgener or label YALL. That's a problem for YALL and Hetro folks to figure out. Don't come come for us we were given this world we didn't make it tink tink. I remember 30 yrs ago when I first heard the word Transgender . I didn't freak out I accepted Trans folks as part of the family. I struggled with my self for years and now I had information. If anything I felt forced to identify as a Stud. A term I didn't know about and didn't appreciate people putting in a box I didn't feel comfortable being in. So why in the hell would I do that to someone else make it make since. Trans folks are not the enemy we are not forcing ourselves on anyone. However YALL are desperately trying to eliminate us but why . We are just living in our truth no one said it had to YALL truth. Stay WOKE 😂

Believing we have reached "peak woke" is a grave error. The second we become complacent again, they will be back with greater force and more refined strategies. This operation of theirs works like a ratchet.

Danke!

TERF Alert!!!

I admire Kathleen immensely. But not just because of the content of what she says. Because of her commitment to truth and clarity, and to intellectual humility. Her commitment to the concept of rational discussion and calm debate, the thrashing out of ideas while respecting all participants, as a means for our society to move closer to truth and clarity about things. How a person with such a quietly spoken and shy sort of demeanour, especially one who is open and willing to discuss ideas and admit if she's wrong and adopt new ideas that make sense, has attracted such a such a large yet vapid protest movement spouting boisterous vitriol, is amazing. But I don't think it reflects badly on her at all. It's just the highschool bullies, who always were devoid of substance, all growed up now. And maybe a few sheep-like NPCs following them.

Secoriea Turner RIP

Because it isn't of God.

If there are more than two genders or sex where are they then ?

Just a tip for those listening to this video...slow down the speed when Gaudiano is speaking...it can be hard to keep up at his speed of talking.

Kathleen epitomises beautifully reasoned discourse, she’s a real role model.

Keep speaking up Kathleen Stock- your voice,alongside JK Rowling,Kellie Jay Keen,Helen Joyce among others. We need your voices to keep reality alive and preserve children’s lives and their health. I really like the way you refer to society as ‘so-called progressive’, when in all actuality it is regressive,perpetuating misogyny. Keep on speaking up ❤🙏❤️

50 mins in, John.....to be clear. there is ZERO 'honour' in a Man forcing his way into Female Sports let alone Female Toilets, Changing areas, Rape & DV Centres/Refuges/Prisons/Groups etc.

Brilliant interview with the extremely brave & intelligent Kathleen Stock 👏 👏 👏

I find Kathleen's mockery of trans people concerning, she wants tolerance and understanding as a lesbian, but can't show the same tolerance and understanding towards trans people...she's been a bully, she called transwomen rapist, and called for the legal right to be offensive; it's incredible when she whimpers what have I done to make students so upset, and it's all political correctness at fault...Kathleen is a disgrace...

Our identity is, to put it in Kant’s terms, always pathological and bespeaks heteronomy rather than autonomy.

the trans-ideology movement is basically a non traditional men's rights movement, because it is made up by men, mainly who have fettishes, or gay men who want to pretend (because maybe they think they will be better accepted) that they are not gay men...of course, not many people would have follow this movement if it was seen for what it is, so it had attach itself to another different movement with actual legitimacy , which is the gay's right movement, indeed we should protect people of all sexual orientations, but this trans-ideology is actually very anti gay and anti woman exactly because it is a men's movement!

Nice conversation, but they seem to sidestep the 'why' behind the data highlighting differences between groups. Instead of exploring whether these differences in outcomes reflect inherent disparities between the groups-such as variations in interest, ability, or other factors-it remains vague and lacks a clear analysis or explanation. The remark about children towards the end shows some progress, but it seems like Gaudiano has a blind spot in his thinking.

1:09:01 lol. That's the heart of it. So, he's found a solution to a problem that he doesn't understand? How does that work, exactly ?

That was terrific. Thank you both so much. Best thing I learned studying philosophy was that people can reason in all sorts of different ways and to all sorts of conclusions, with all sorts of justifications and we are richer when we make space for different ideas to be heard, and when we learn how to challenge and critique our reasonings and grow our understandings about the world, respectfully and without attacking each other. Kathleen you do this so well. I wish we taught philosophy and critical thinking to little kids in school. I didn't even really know what it was til I was in my 30s... Glad I found out!

Well, Kaufmann’s reduction and metrics is the “killer”here… They aren’t “wrong”, science, statistics or our current economic narrative support this. However, context, change (time), and force from social constructs are lacking. Also, some metrics are averages (group, entity), others are “individual”. So why would “the left” lean towards conformity? Maybe because most people under 40 indeed must conform more than their (grand-) parents. In a competitive reality, abandoning competition is easily imagined. By which way most countermovements internalise and negate what they experience in their time. I sorely miss good dialectics here - not to dismiss _anything,_ but realise externalities and better re-internalise ontological aspects. Science is great, but seldom in a “vacuum” focusing on what we do. We also need to _be_ - as human beings (not h. doings)…! 😊 (And sure, as I came to Gaudiano - he did all that… 🙈😅)

Kathleen Stock, Helen Joyce, Maya Forstatter, Kelly Jay Keen (Posie Parker), Dr Hilary Cass, JK Rowling ... Thank you for courage to stand against the aggression, the vitriol and the malice of power grabbers. 🎀🏆

An incredible conversation between two philosophers who really know how to get to the heart of each and every issue regarding sex and gender identity. Thank you!

The issue I imagine people had with the way you are talking about this, is you continually suggest or say outright that being trans is along the lines of a social contagion when the amount of transphobia and actual evidence that exists pushes the actual opposite effect. Some people are born trans and nobody is pushing lesbians to be trans (any chance someone might be projecting?).. questioning your gender identity doesn’t have to be a negative thing and it can help us all understand the ways we exist in our society. Sadly all this does it push TERF narratives and hateful perceptions

I wonder how Jordan B. Peterson feels about Canadian academia. Probably MUCH different than the VAST majority of professors, administration, staff, and students who are very careful to self censor their thoughts and expression. The academy is rotten throughout. From the permeated putrefaction of the Ivory Tower President, on down. Yes, the intolerance of tolerance, and the uniformity of diversity. A sham with the artifice of collegial conformity that shuns actual diverse talent.

Hiya Kathleen you are a fabulous, kind, humane human being, who genuinely tries to help people. The hatred you have been subjected to is so unjust it makes my blood boil. As you said, you don't have many issues with trans people but with trans activists and they are an entirely different thing altogether. Trans activists are evil and are not interested in helping anyone, least of all children who are always the most vulnerable in society. The bullying tactics they use elicits fear out of far too many of your colleagues and probably leaves you feeling isolated but as long as there are people like yourself and Jordan Peterson around who speak the truth then the activist will not win. Every victory you win slows down their progress and helps to keep children safe. Not very long ago the mutilation of children would be considered a most heinous crime and it will be again. When enough people come to their senses or your colleagues find their courage, the monstrous ideology behind this will be put under a spotlight as will the 'people' funding the trans activist movement and I wouldn't want to be in their shoes when it does. Nor would I want to be one of the butchers cutting bits off kids. I know a high percentage of teenage girls have problems with self image during puberty and that is something that has always happened. But now in this day it has become an extremely dangerous time for young women with 'teachers' asking them leading questions and guiding impressionable young minds down a very dark path. What used to be referred to as a tom boy can now lead to real tragedy and those guidance teachers also have a lot to answer for although some of them may actually think they are helping. Lets face it, being a fellow Scot, you'll know most school teachers are thick as mince. Tavistock was shut down when enough people became aware of it. The Cass report and the work you do all help shine a light and for all the intimidation that trans activists and Stonewall are guilty of......................as of today twenty three thousand people have watched this video and virtually all of us are behind you and we are all talking. The Internet is a two edged sword, unlike mainstream media, it cannot be controlled and once the information is out there, it spreads. Whilst they try and curb free speech they will ultimately loose, they just haven't thought it through to a logical conclusion. Equality is something our ancestors strived for and attained. We have had it for many decades and a society that has attained that level of freedom will not give it up. Although both main parties haven't been working for the British Public for about three decades there is light at the end of the tunnel in the Reform Party. Though there is a hell of a lot to be put right the will to do so is growing and the flag that guarantees all our rights, the Union Flag will be dominant again replacing the pride flag and those malign forces that hide behind it hurling abuse. Thank you Kathleen......

I'm a traditional leftist and it's outrageous how the left has bought into postmodernist gender ideology that completely contradicts Dialectical Materialism (Marxism) yet they pretend there's no theoretical issues or major contradictions. And the left keeps wondering why they cannot connect with working class people!